Nora Vargas’ Abrupt, Unexplained Resignation Shocks County
- Media
- Dec 23, 2024
- 5 min read
Vargas, newly re-elected to a four-year term, cited ‘personal safety and security reasons’ for her sudden departure. She had faced mounting criticism in her district following a series of perceived missteps and fights with onetime allies.
San Diego County Board of Supervisors Chair Nora Vargas abruptly resigned on Friday, shocking the county’s political establishment and ushering in a period of instability as county leaders grapple with homelessness, immigration, an incoming presidential administration and other major challenges.
Vargas, who won re-election to the board just one month ago, said in a statement that she was stepping down due to unspecified “personal safety and security reasons.”
Vargas had faced a torrent of hateful online comments after spearheading a recent county policy that aimed to limit cooperation with federal immigration officials in advance of incoming President-elect Donald Trump’s promised crackdown on undocumented immigrants. She has spoken often of her dismay at mounting public disruptions in Board of Supervisors meetings and said she has faced death threats and other extreme forms of harassment.
“I have stalkers, I have people who harass me on phones, there’s all sorts of things,” she said during a recent Board of Supervisors discussion about changing meeting rules to prevent disruptions.
But Vargas also had alienated a growing number of onetime supporters in her district and received a surprisingly low number of votes in her re-election race against an underfunded and virtually unknown Republican opponent.
Though she took office in 2021 with great fanfare as the first Latina on the Board of Supervisors, she proceeded to engage in a series of high-profile disputes with organized labor groups who once supported her and was broadly perceived by residents near the Tijuana River as ineffective in responding to the region’s ongoing sewage crisis.
Multiple legal claims accused her and members of her staff of making racist comments about prospective employees and engaging in backroom maneuvers to prevent Michael Vu, a longtime county administrator, from landing a coveted role as the county’s chief administrative officer because, according to a claim filed by Vu, Vargas wanted “a Hispanic or Black” candidate instead. Vargas and members of her staff have denied that they discriminated against potential employees.
This year, the board endured a series of high-profile setbacks under Vargas’ leadership, including the abrupt cancellation of a homeless housing project, delays in establishing an aid center for migrants and the collapse of a proposed collaboration with the University of California, San Diego to establish a hub for mental health treatment.
Vargas’ resignation was so sudden and apparently unplanned, staff members in her office said they learned about it only moments before an official announcement was emailed to reporters at 11 a.m. Friday. Vargas declined interview requests and staff in her office referred to her resignation statement when asked for further comment.
In her statement, Vargas said: “It has been my honor to serve in public office during unprecedented times…My priority has always been our community, ensuring that everyone can be seen, heard and have a chance to thrive.”
“Some of my proudest accomplishments include spearheading disaster response and recovery efforts, navigating the complexities of the pandemic and driving systemic change so that our government serves all members of our community, not just a select few,” the statement said.
Vargas’ departure from the Board of Supervisors comes as county leaders face a series of difficult decisions about cooperating with the incoming Trump administration, addressing the San Diego region’s acute lack of affordable housing and implementing controversial state reforms aimed at expanding and toughening drug and mental health treatment.
The sudden vacancy on the Board is the second time in two years an abrupt resignation upended county politics and threw major policy decisions into limbo. Former Board Chair Nathan Fletcher resigned in 2023 and began treatment for alcohol abuse amid allegations that he groped and pursued an unwanted sexual relationship with a Metropolitan Transportation Authority employee.
Supervisors are expected to decide at their next meeting on Jan. 6 whether to appoint a replacement for Vargas or schedule a special election in her district, which encompasses a large swath of southwest San Diego County.
Until a replacement is named, the five-member board, up to now dominated by a 3-2 Democratic majority, will be evenly split between Democrats and Republicans, further complicating policymaking.
In a statement, Board of Supervisors Vice Chair Terra Lawson-Remer, who recently tangled with Vargas over whether to seek federal environmental superfund status for the Tijuana River Valley, assured voters that “the work and new direction of the county will continue moving forward…I’m confident in my fellow county supervisors, executive team and employees, and we will keep tackling the major issues facing our region.”
Republican Supervisor Jim Desmond, who also recently tangled with Vargas over county immigration policy, had a droller take on the day’s news. “Never a dull moment in the county…” he posted on the social media site X shortly after Vargas’ announcement.
Political insiders said several elected leaders in Vargas’ district were already reaching out to potential supporters to line up endorsements and gauge their chances. Names mentioned as possible successors include Imperial Beach Mayor Paloma Aguirre, San Diego City Councilmember Vivian Moreno, state Assembly member David Alvarez, Chula Vista City Councilmember Carolina Chavez and National City Councilmember Jose Rodriguez.
One local leader is already declaring his intent to run for the seat. “I am definitely considering running for county supervisor,” Chula Vista Mayor John McCann said in a text message Friday afternoon. McCann, a Republican, said he would wait until supervisors call a special election to make an official announcement.
Several other politicians contacted for this story did not respond to questions about their intention to seek to replace Vargas on the board.
Rodriguez, of National City, said he was not currently contemplating a run for Vargas’ seat. But he acknowledged that “of course every politician in South Bay who has held a position of leadership is thinking about it. Let’s be frank.”
Though Rodriguez had what he called his own “differences” with Vargas, he commended “her work over the last four years” and said, “I wish her well in any future venture.”
Rodriguez said he also sympathized with Vargas’ claim that her resignation from the Board of Supervisors was motivated in part by fears for her safety. As someone who himself has fielded racially tinged rhetoric from audience members during public meetings, Rodriguez said that Vargas, as a Latina, had been especially vulnerable amid San Diego County’s increasingly vitriolic political debate.
“I’ve noticed a special animosity against her,” Rodriguez said. “It’s either her positions or who she is, and that’s very unfortunate.”
Kelvin Barrios, political director for a prominent union representing laborers in San Diego County, said news of Vargas’ resignation caught him and other political insiders “by surprise.”
“We woke up this morning and we had five board members, and a couple hours later that’s no longer the case,” Barrios said. “We didn’t know anything about it ahead of time.”
Barrios said he and other political observers now will be watching to see who vies to replace Vargas and what her departure means for county policy at a time of increasing political volatility.
“It was a difficult year for the Board of Supervisors,” Barrios said. “We are looking at having a split two-two on the board and [we will be] watching how that dynamic will play out.”
Written by Jim Hinch | December 20, 2024 | Voice of San Diego
Lisa Halverstadt, MacKenzie Elmer and Jakob McWhinney contributed reporting.
Comments